We're Sadly, Dangerously Not Too 'Tapped Out' for More Bailouts
Listen · 4 min
Generated with AI technology.

The problem isn’t the U.S.’s national debt, it’s the U.S.’s national debt. There’s a major, unspoken peril in the latter that’s not touched on by those focused on the former.
Take the excellent Nicole Gelinas at the Manhattan Institute. In a recent piece for City Journal, Gelinas made a case that the days of the U.S. Treasury bailing out failed corporations are over, that with yields rising on Treasury debt, the U.S. is too “tapped out” to continue saving businesses that investors have passed on saving. Gelinas is right about the horrors of bailouts, but the long-time deficit hawk in her could probably be convinced that she’s incorrect about the U.S.’s borrowing capacity.
Starting with bailouts, they shouldn’t happen. Ever. Precisely because we love banks, investment banks, carmakers, and surely other businesses that have pursued government help, we should love those same businesses enough to let them fail. Unfettered failure is the freedom and pro-growth solution. Always.
If it weren’t, Silicon Valley would be desperately poor since just about every startup seeded out there fails. Actual, business decline is what powers Silicon Valley’s greatness as no businesses remain in business (while consuming precious human and physical capital) if they’re not advancing commercial progress.
Worse about bailouts is that governments don’t just hand over the money and walk away. They want a little or a lot of control, thus sapping the vitality of the business and industry they’re in. Gelinas is once again right that there shouldn’t be any more bailouts.
Where she could probably be convinced she’s incorrect is in her assertion that bailouts themselves cause businesses to take dangerous risks, to swing for the proverbial fences since profits are privatized while failures are socialized. Conservatives and libertarians have long dined out on the previous notion, but can Gelinas name even one corporate CEO who emerged from a federal bailout with reputation intact?
Considering how investors in failed corporations have been treated by governments with bailout money in hand, can she name investors eternally blithe to corporate risk since governments sometimes provide cushions? The simple truth glossed over by Gelinas is that the cost of being wrong for investors is incredibly steep. For evidence, see the return-based rankings of portfolio managers, not to mention the genius of compounding itself.
Back to Treasury yields, they’re at highs last seen in 2007; this, despite Treasury secretary Scott Bessent’s efforts to overwhelm the markets with Treasury buying. Gelinas sees this as evidence that there’s no longer a substantive market for Treasury debt, and hence, no investor appetite to buy the bonds Treasury would have to float to bail out future failures. Gelinas’s read of the market is arguably flawed.
While it’s true that Treasury yields are at highs last seen in 2007, keep in mind that the total national debt in’07 was roughly $7 trillion. So, despite debt up nearly 6x since that time, the deepest markets in the world are charging Treasury the same rate of interest.
Which is an indication that Treasury is nowhere close to being “tapped out.” Said another way, the surest sign Treasury investors don’t fear Treasury’s debt is all of Treasury’s debt. It speaks to the real problem.
The problem is once again not the national debt, it’s the national debt. Get it? The rich are so excessively taxed in the U.S. (to focus on relative tax rates is to completely miss the point) that investors are as comfortable with $40 trillion debt as they were with $7 trillion. There’s your crisis, though one no one’s talking about.
Originally published on Real Clear Markets.