Peggy Noonan Is Welcome to Her AI Opinions, Not Her AI Facts
Listen · 4 min
Generated with AI technology.

According to Wall Street Journal opinion columnist Peggy Noonan, artificial intelligence (AI) may cure cancer, but also may destroy the world. These are opinions held by Noonan.
In her latest column, Noonan moved beyond opinion. Writing about the Nvidia co-founder Jensen Huang, Noonan asserted that “His company designs the most advanced computer chips in the world. AI systems can hardly be built without them, and China hasn’t been able to manufacture them.” Noonan’s first sentence is true, the other false.
The sentence that’s true calls for a digression. During WWI, exports from the U.S. to Scandinavian countries surged. With the U.S. having placed an embargo on Germany, American producers still traded with the Germans. Get it?
Fast forward to 1973, the Arab members of OPEC embargoed the U.S. Same story. The embargo was wholly symbolic. “Arab oil” continued to flow to the U.S., albeit via the intermediaries the Arab nations sold to. The U.S. has had a multi-decade export ban placed on Iran, but Apple can claim 11% market share there in the smartphone category.
Noonan is correct that Nvidia’s AI chips are the “most advanced in the world.” That’s not an opinion, it’s a fact revealed in Nvidia’s valuation.
What this tells us is that Alice Huang or none, Nvidia’s AI chips were going to make their way to China. Jensen Huang could be the biggest China hawk in all of tech, but Nvidia’s chips were going to flow not just to China, but also to Russia, North Korea, and Iran assuming demand from the countries mentioned. See above for an explanation of what is basic economics. There’s no controlling the final destination of any good.
Noonan claims Jensen Huang “appears to have been helping China win the future,” which isn’t serious. The AI chips were once again going to reach China no matter what.
Back to Noonan’s contention that “AI systems can hardly be built without them [Nvidia’s most advanced chips], and China hasn’t been able to manufacture them.” No, this isn’t true. See DeepSeek’s R1 launched in 2025. It was created with lesser Nvidia chips “approved” by the U.S. political class. Anthropic relies heavily on Amazon's Trainium2 chips, which are legal to export.
Let’s add that contra Noonan, AI chips are in fact being created by Chinese producers, including Huawei. Just as Huawei worked around U.S. export controls meant to slow the creation of a smartphone competitive with Apple’s iPhone, so is Huawei doing the same here. Huawei trains its AI models not on Nvidia chips, but through its proprietary semiconductor subsidiary, HiSilicon. The latter is based in Shenzhen.
Which has been Jensen Huang’s point all along: precisely because some of the world’s greatest AI minds are in China, export controls meant to slow China’s advance down won’t stop China as much as they’ll cause China’s greatest AI talent to turn inward to producers within the country.
Noonan once again contends that Jensen Huang “appears to have been helping China win the future,” but it’s the export controls Noonan prefers that will do the most to help China build an AI future, though one without Nvidia. Noonan has long disdained Silicon Valley, only for AI in Silicon Valley to really boost her agitation. Still, there’s opinion and there’s fact.
About Jensen Huang and Nvidia, Noonan is manufacturing fact about what Huang was doing to support her opinion. In truth, what’s false about what she wrote supports what’s factual: the export controls on Nvidia that she prefers will ultimately help China achieve AI autarky, which is why the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) wanted them all along.
Originally published on Real Clear Markets.